Insurance & RiskIntermediate5 min read

Picking an insurer: financial strength and complaint records, not just price

The cheapest premium from a company that fights every claim or can't pay them is a bad trade. Two free checks separate a good insurer from a cheap one.

Insurance is a promise to pay in the future, which means the company behind the promise matters as much as the price. A rock-bottom premium from an insurer that disputes claims, pays slowly, or lacks the reserves to cover a wave of losses is a false economy — you find out exactly when you can least afford to. Two free, public checks tell you most of what you need: how financially strong the insurer is, and how often its customers complain.

Financial strength ratings

Independent agencies grade insurers on their ability to pay claims. AM Best is the best-known and most insurance-specific; Standard & Poor's, Moody's, and Fitch also rate insurers. Higher grades (an A-range Best rating, for example) signal strong reserves and a low chance the company can't meet its obligations after a big catastrophe. This matters most in disaster-prone regions, where a wave of simultaneous claims can strain a thinly capitalized carrier — the moment you most need the promise to hold.

The complaint index tells you how they treat claims

The NAIC (National Association of Insurance Commissioners) publishes a complaint index for each insurer. A score of 1.0 is the national average; below 1.0 means fewer complaints than average for the company's size, above 1.0 means more. It's a fast, standardized read on how an insurer actually handles claims and service — a strong financial rating tells you they CAN pay, and a low complaint index suggests they WILL, without a fight.

The full picture before you switch

Financial strength rating (AM Best and one other agency): confirms the insurer can pay claims after a catastrophe.
NAIC complaint index: a below-average score signals smoother claims handling.
J.D. Power claims satisfaction rankings: independent customer surveys on the claims experience specifically.
Your state insurance department: complaint data and any regulatory actions against the carrier.

Cheapest is not the same as best

A carrier can offer the lowest premium precisely because it underprices claims-paying quality — slow adjusters, lowball first offers, aggressive denials. When two quotes are close at matching coverage, the tiebreaker should be financial strength and complaint records, not the last twenty dollars of premium. You're buying a claims experience you hope to never use, but must be able to rely on if you do.

The bottom line

An insurance policy is only as good as the company standing behind it. Before choosing or switching carriers, spend five minutes on two free checks: a financial strength rating (can they pay?) and the NAIC complaint index (will they pay without a fight?). Let those, not the last few dollars of premium, break ties between close quotes — because the value of insurance is entirely in the claim you hope never comes.

Check your understanding

1 of 3

What does a financial strength rating (like AM Best's) tell you about an insurer?

Not quite — try again.

The Worth letter

Get smarter about money every week

One email, no spam — practical guides and Worth updates. Unsubscribe anytime.

Put this into practice

Worth tracks your accounts, budgets, and goals — so the concepts in this article aren't just theory.

Start free trial